December 30, 2004

Understand The Welfare State

I have just read a wonderful book pandering to my prejudices, and I would recommend you to read it too.

James Bartholomew's The Welfare State We're In is a refreshingly critical book about the Welfare State. Easy to read, well argued, informative, historical, provocative, and well referenced.

In some ways it is depressing to contemplate the immense waste and destruction wrought by the often well meaning people who have brought about the welfare state, but it makes me optimistic that someone can pull together such a cogent and devastating critique, showing not just how ineffective and counter-productive the welfare state is, but how it helps explain and give a perspective to the enormous increase in crime and change in morality since the 1950s.

It is sometimes hard to imagine how anyone can any longer begin to challenge the vested interests behind the welfare state, and then reform it, but we have to start with rational critiques like this one, showing how things really are, how they once were, how they might have been, which then point to how things might yet be.

Read it now.

See the website too.

December 29, 2004

Subverting British Justice

The ejection of the Law Lords from the House of Lords has moved still closer with the recent announcement that the new Supreme Court will be sited in Middlesex Guildhall.

And so is brought closer another step in the erosion of the UK's constitutional wellbeing.

The change is not being made because there is or has been any problem with the quality of judging or judicial decision making or any lack of judicial independence (far from it), but to correct the supposed failure of the British constitution to separate the judiciary from the executive and legislature, thought to be implicitly required by the Human Rights Act.

The trouble is that removing the Law Lords from the House of Lords removes them from the most independently minded part of our constitutional structure.

As members of the House of Lords, the Law Lords have an independent standing which will be denied them under a government minister. At the moment they can look to the House of Lords itself for protection in the event of a dispute or crisis. And while the principal Law Lord is the Lord Chancellor, himself an eminent professional lawyer, and the Speaker of the House of Lords, he has a status, role, and standing giving him an independence and influence quite unlike other members of the Cabinet, and as a matter of professional integrity, a personal interest in defending the judiciary. It is significant that in Lord Falconer, the current Lord Chancellor doing the hatchet job we have a placeman who does not match the personal and professional profile required for the Lord Chancellorship (but then he was never intended for such a role - it had supposedly been abolished in a press release).

Isolated from the Lords, and without a standing independent of their government department, and run by an ordinary Minister the judiciary's dynamics will change. Their selection will reflect political priorities far more than today - the selection panels can have no true independence from the politicians: our safeguard today is that the Lord Chancellor is not an ordinary politician. The change will affect the career calculations of our leading lawyers, and as the status of our senior judges is diminished, this will in future affect the quality of our leading judges. Above all, it changes the environment in which the senior judges will work, and makes them more vulnerable to political and bureaucratic pressure. It will not just be most senior judges who will be affected - any change in their status and independence will have a knock on effect on the judges below them: we are moving the whole judiciary to an inferior status, making it much more subject to the government, and isolating it from Parliament.

If the separation of powers is so important - how then can the system of drawing the government from Parliament, i.e. the legislature, be countenanced? The whole idea of applying a separation of powers to the UK is based on a misconception of our system of government. Perhaps the intention is in time also to remove the monarchy and elect an executive president?

December 28, 2004

State Bullies Fail Children

Why is there not more support for education vouchers and other schemes to give power and choice back to parents, and away from government and its bureaucracies?

See Samizdata.net for another example of the failure of the state system to provide for the needs of children as individuals, and worse, to undermine and bully the attempts of parents who want something a little different for their child.

My own experience with Hampshire's LEA leaves me with every sympathy for the Williams. Hampshire still believes it can act however it pleases, and then stonewall any attempt to bring it to account.

December 27, 2004

New Drugs Tests For Motorists

The Telegraph reports drivers face new roadside tests, such as standing on one leg:

If police judge that the suspect's reactions indicate that driving ability has been impaired by illegal or certain prescription drugs, charges could follow.

Surely what should determine fitness to drive is whether you can drive properly, whatever you may or may not have been consuming?

Useless Tory Proposal To Cut MPs

The Tories will cut the numbers of MPs to save £30m:
The Conservatives have said they will cut the number of MPs, ministers and special advisers by a fifth within five years if they win the election.
Another proposal showing the Tories have lost the plot.

Will it enhance MPs' independence? No, because British political parties are increasingly centralised and state funded. The central party machines dominate MP selection, and are insulated from local party associations by state funding.

Will it reduce the payroll vote? No, the number of ministers is not determined by the number of MPs. If a governing party wished to reduce the number of ministries they could do it now.

Will it make for a better Parliament? No, it reduces the pool of available talent. It is what MPs do that matters, not how many of them there are. Far better if MPs actually scrutinised legislation, instead of passing endless enabling Acts which let the UK/EU government legislate by regulation.

Will it save money? Marginally, perhaps, but £30 million is so little in the overall scheme of government expenditure. Leaving the EU would save far more on MEP salaries and expenses - apart from the benefit of having the freedom to reduce the £100 billion annual cost of regulation.

Will it make for a smaller state? The number of MPs has nothing to do with the size of the government machine, or the range of activities it undertakes, or the volume or complexity of regulations. In that sense reducing the number of MPs is irrelevant. It might make some sense if the government's role in society was substantially reduced, and politicians had little to do, but reducing the role of government has to come first. At the moment the problem is that MPs are not doing what they should be doing, viz. representing the electorate and scrutinising legislation and the executive.

Come on Conservative Party! Surely you can do better than this?

December 23, 2004

Britain - Land Of The Ever Less Free

The Telegraph reports:
Up to 600,000 people each year who apply for their first passports will have to attend an interview under a scheme announced yesterday by the Home Office.
It is ever clearer that the government regards itself as master, and we all live on sufferance. Travel is a privilege, and the passport is not supplied to clear the way and help us travel, but as a means of control.

The purpose behind ID cards is the creation of a unified national database - principally for the surveillance and control of British nationals (the 26 million transient foreigners annually are not to be subject to it, thereby negating many of the supposed reasons for having it).

Now the government announces all adult passports issued for the first time will require an interview from 2006, at one of 70 centres around the country. This means travel, and travel expense, and time off work, and time waiting for interview, and time being interviewed, and time being processed and approved. And being subject and beholden to some self-important official, and whatever personal questions he chooses to ask. An intrusion into one's life and privacy.

All for our own good, of course. I don't think so.

What the government announcement is really saying is that it is setting up the system by which, when the ID cards come along, we will all have to go along for "interviews" to get our passports, whether for the first time or not.

Britain becomes less attractive by the day, and, so long as they subscribe to this evil, it is another reason the Tories will not get my vote. Time for the 1952 Committee.

December 22, 2004

Right Not To Be Offended?

We have just seen a play close in Birmingham because Sikh protesters used violence, and the forces of law and government lacked the will to defend free speech, which if it is to mean anything means allowing people to offend others.

I think Mark Steyn has it right when (discussing mainly USA examples) he says:

The elevation of the right not to be offended into the bedrock principle of democratic society will, in the end, tear it apart.
If this is a consequence of the creation of a multicultural society, it is a heavy price to pay.

Government To Risk Coaching Witnesses

The Government is hell bent on dismantling the traditional safeguards of the criminal justice system. It now wants to let prosecution lawyers interview prosecution witnesses - a practice currently prohibited because of the risk of the prosecution coaching its witnesses, and tainting their evidence.

A particular motivation seems to be the Damilola Tayor case, where a young witness proved unreliable. In other words, the Government is keen that child and other vulnerable witnesses be interviewed before trial.

Yet it is child and other vulnerable witnesses in a trial that are at especial risk of being used by others; are most at risk of being coached; and pose special problems in being interviewed. See relevant article on child interviews.

Defence lawyers would be excluded from these interviews, further reducing confidence in the proposed system.

To compound the problem the Government is saying there is no need for these interviews to be recorded by video or audio, and that only written notes need be made.

In other words, there will be no record of the interview independent of the prosecution; no possibility of evaluating the effect of the interview on the witness; and no possibility of assessing the prosecutor's use of the interview. And of course, the prosecution have a career interest in successful prosecutions.

Liberty has already submitted cogent criticism of the proposals, which were floated at least a year ago.

Hard cases make bad law.

December 17, 2004

Straw Repudiates Law Lords' Decision

It is ironic that Jack Straw invokes the special immigration appeals tribunal to support his case:

Mr Straw told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "The people concerned have a right of appeal to a special immigration appeals tribunal, which is chaired by a high court judge, and on each of the cases of the people currently detained the decision to certify them as requiring detention was approved by that court.
Because as the BBC reports:

When the men were first held, they took their cases to the Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC).

The commission ruled on 30 July, 2002 that the anti-terror act unjustifiably discriminated against foreign nationals as British people could not be held in the same way.
The Court of Appeal felt bound to overrule the Commission: hence the House of Lords judgment.